Employer Liable: Failure to Investigate Sexual Harassment Claim

Table of Contents

Share at:

A Queensland tribunal recently found an employer was liable after it failed to properly investigate a sexual harassment claim brought by one of its employees. (McCauley v Club Resort Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2013] QCAT 243 (13 May 2013))

The case involved a sexual harassment claim made by a food and beverage attendant against a chef with whom she worked. The attendant claimed the chef had made derogatory comments to her over a number of days and made growling noises in her ear and around her neck.

The tribunal was very unimpressed with the way in which the investigation was conducted. The HR Manager who conducted the investigation was criticised for:

  • Failing to obtain a full account of events from the attendant.
  • Not putting the attendant’s account to the chef (the first time her version of events was put to him was at the hearing).
  • Not advising the attendant that an investigator had been appointed.
  • Not interviewing other witnesses said to be present when some of the derogatory comments were made.

The employer’s response to the complaint and its subsequent investigation were described as “inept and unprofessional”, and the employer was ordered to pay the attendant $35,490 by way of compensation.

Take claims of workplace harassment seriously

This unfortunate example serves as a reminder for employers when dealing with a complaint by an employee:

  • Ensure you have clearly communicated workplace policies that set out what constitutes acceptable and unacceptable behaviour.
  • Have a clearly communicated complaints process in place to deal with complaints about breaches of these policies.
  • Consistently follow the complaints process.

You cannot always control how your employees behave; but if you fail to follow up complaints of harassment in a professional manner, it could cost you dearly.

Christine Broad, Solicitor, BlandsLaw

Don’t know where to start? Contact us on 1800 529 728 to learn more about customising legal documents and obtaining a fixed-fee quote from Australia’s largest lawyer marketplace.

Share at:

Simplify creating legal documents today

Browse through Lawpath's AI tools which can be used to draft, review and refine legal documents today!

Related Articles

Is a Verbal Agreement Binding and Can It Hold Up in Court?

Does a verbal agreement have the same legal force as a written agreement? Get the answers you've been searching for in our guide.

How to Terminate a Contract by Mutual Consent

There are many legal ways to terminate a contract. Mutual consent is the most civilised way to terminate if absolutely necessary. Find out more here.

How to Start Your Own Truck Driving Business: The Steps to Get You on The Road

Are you thinking of starting a truck driving business? Learn how to get registered, become a popular brand and promote growth.
Founder working at a laptop and notebook on a wooden desk while setting up a new company

10 Common Company Registration Mistakes to Avoid in Australia

Avoid the 10 most common company registration mistakes in Australia, from director ID timing and share errors to addresses, ABNs and the annual review.

How to Value a Business in Australia: The Methods Explained

From 1 July 2027, what your business was worth on 30 June sets your future CGT bill, even if you never sell. Here's why it matters.

Are Merchant Fees Tax Deductible? GST and Tax Rules for Businesses

Understand when merchant fees are deductible in Australia and how to record them correctly for tax and GST purposes.