Our free underpayment calculator (below) estimates what underpaying staff could cost your business. Enter how many employees were short-paid, by how much a week, for how long and how it happened. It returns the back pay inside the 6-year limit and the maximum civil and criminal penalties that could apply.
When you find an underpayment, it’s natural to worry about the penalty first. The back pay is money you owe either way. The penalty figures are ceilings, and only a court can set the actual amount.
How is back pay for an underpayment worked out?
Back pay is the gap between what you paid and what the award, enterprise agreement or National Employment Standards required, for every week it happened. You owe it whether the underpayment was a typo or a choice.
Our calculator multiplies three inputs: the number of employees, the average weekly shortfall, and the weeks inside the claim window. It counts the days inclusively and divides by 7, so 104 weeks of $70 short for 4 people is $29,120.
Claims go back 6 years. Under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), a court claim about a contravention must be made within 6 years after it (s 544). Anything older shows separately in the calculator and isn’t added to the total.
Two costs sit on top that the calculator leaves out. When a court orders unpaid wages to be paid, it must add interest if asked, unless there’s good reason not to (s 547). And if the back pay is for ordinary hours, super is owed on it too. The ATO counts back pay for ordinary hours as qualifying earnings for super, and super that isn’t paid on time attracts the super guarantee charge.
How do underpayments usually happen?
Underpayments often start with a pay setting that was right once and then went out of date.
- An annual salary that doesn’t cover the award. A salary can look generous and still fall short once overtime, penalty rates and leave loading are added up. Our guide to whether a salary covers overtime and penalty rates walks through the test.
- Penalty rates missed on weekends, public holidays or late shifts. See when you have to pay penalty rates.
- A pay rise that never made it into payroll. Annual wage review increases to the minimum wage and award rates generally start on 1 July each year. Our minimum wage checker shows the current National Minimum Wage.
- The wrong award or classification. One level too low for two years looks a lot like the first worked example below.
For the law changes behind the current rules, read our guide to the underpayment laws.
What are the maximum penalties for underpaying staff from 1 July 2026?
Civil penalty maximums are set in penalty units. For contraventions on or after 1 July 2026, a penalty unit is $364, under the 2026 penalty unit instrument. From 7 November 2024 to 30 June 2026 it was $330, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics.
| Who the employer is | Maximum per contravention | Serious contravention (knowing or reckless) |
|---|---|---|
| Individual, including a sole trader (60 / 600 units) | $21,840 | $218,400 |
| Company with fewer than 15 employees (5 times) | $109,200 | $1,092,000 |
| Company with 15 or more employees (25 times) | $546,000, or 3 times the underpayment if higher | $5,460,000, or 3 times the underpayment if higher |
These figures come from the Fair Work Ombudsman‘s litigation page. They are maximums per contravention. A court sets the actual penalty case by case.
A small business employer has fewer than 15 employees. The count includes associated entities and regular and systematic casuals. For the higher company maximums, the headcount is tested when the court application is made, not when the underpayment happened. A company that grew from 12 to 16 staff while the problem ran, and still has 16 when a claim is filed, faces the larger figures.
When can the penalty be 3 times the underpayment?
For a company with 15 or more employees, a contravention relating to an underpayment from 1 January 2025 can carry a maximum of 3 times the underpayment, if that’s higher than the fixed figure (s 546(2A)). The same comparison applies to the serious figure.
Here’s where that test starts to matter. Three times the underpayment passes $546,000 once the underpayment is more than $182,000. It passes the $5,460,000 serious figure above $1,820,000. Below those amounts, the fixed maximums are the higher number.
The calculator treats the whole underpayment as one contravention when it applies this test. That’s a simplification. Courts group or split contraventions case by case, so read the 3 times figure as a guide to scale. The test doesn’t apply to individuals involved in the contravention, such as directors.
What makes an underpayment a serious contravention?
Since 27 February 2024, a contravention is serious if it was knowing or reckless (s 557A). Before then, it had to be both knowing and part of a systematic pattern of conduct.
Reckless has a set meaning: you were aware of a substantial risk that the underpayment would happen and, given what you knew, it was unjustifiable to take that risk (s 557A(2)). You don’t need to know the exact amount owed for it to be serious. Serious maximums are 10 times the ordinary ones.
In the calculator, you pick how the underpayment happened: a mistake, knowing or reckless, or deliberate. If you pick “not sure”, it treats it like a mistake and shows the ordinary maximum as the headline.
Is underpaying staff a crime? The wage theft offence
Sometimes. Since 1 January 2025, intentional underpayment can be a criminal offence under s 327A of the Fair Work Act. It covers intentional conduct that results in a required amount, such as wages, super or other entitlements, not being paid in full when it’s due.
Honest mistakes aren’t covered. The wrong award classification or a missed 1 July rate change, made in good faith, stays a civil matter.
Here are the maximums for offences on or after 1 July 2026, at $364 a penalty unit:
- Individual: up to 10 years’ imprisonment, a fine of the greater of 3 times the underpayment and 5,000 penalty units ($1,820,000), or both.
- Company: a fine of the greater of 3 times the underpayment and 25,000 penalty units ($9,100,000).
For penalties, offences that come from one course of conduct are treated as a single offence (s 327A(8)). The calculator only shows these figures if you choose “deliberate”, and it only counts underpayment from 1 January 2025.
Small businesses get a specific protection. If the Fair Work Ombudsman is satisfied that a small business employer complied with the Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code for that underpayment, it can’t refer the conduct for prosecution (s 327B). The back pay is still owed, and civil penalty proceedings can still be brought.
Can directors and managers be personally liable for underpayments?
Yes. A court can penalise anyone involved in a contravention personally (s 550). That can include a director, a manager or the person who runs payroll.
For contraventions on or after 1 July 2026, the maximum for each involved person is the individual figure: $21,840, or $218,400 if serious. The 3 times underpayment test doesn’t apply to them.
So a Pty Ltd doesn’t fully shield the people running it. The company faces its maximum, and the director can face their own.
Underpayment calculator worked examples
All three use the calculator’s own figures, worked out as at 16 November 2026, with the underpayment stopping on 15 November 2026. Because it stopped after 1 July 2026, the penalty unit is $364.
Example 1: small company, honest mistake
A café run through a Pty Ltd has 9 staff. Four employees were underpaid an average of $70 a week from 18 November 2024 to 15 November 2026, which is 104 weeks.
- Back pay: 4 x $70 x 104 weeks = $29,120 ($7,280 each).
- Maximum civil penalty per contravention: 300 penalty units x $364 = $109,200. If a court found it knowing or reckless: $1,092,000.
- People involved, such as the director: up to $21,840 each, or $218,400 if serious.
Back pay of $29,120 is the real cost. It was a mistake, so the wage theft offence doesn’t apply.
Example 2: company with 15 or more employees, knowing or reckless
A larger employer underpaid 120 employees an average of $45 a week from 6 January 2025 to 15 November 2026, which is 97 weeks.
- Back pay: 120 x $45 x 97 weeks = $523,800.
- Ordinary maximum: 1,500 penalty units x $364 = $546,000. Three times the underpayment, $1,571,400, is higher, so the maximum is $1,571,400.
- Serious maximum (the one that applies here): $5,460,000, which is higher than 3 times the underpayment.
A small weekly gap across a big team adds up. At $45 a week, it’s more than half a million dollars before any penalty.
Example 3: sole trader, deliberate, part of it more than 6 years old
A sole trader underpaid 2 employees $100 a week each from 16 November 2019 to 15 November 2026.
- Claim window: starts 16 November 2020. Back pay inside it: 2,191 days, $62,600. Outside it (366 days): $10,457.14, not counted.
- Civil maximums (individual employer): $21,840, or $218,400 if serious.
- Wage theft offence: only the underpayment from 1 January 2025 counts, $19,542.86. Three times that is $58,628.58, which is less than 5,000 penalty units ($1,820,000). So the maximum fine is $1,820,000, plus up to 10 years’ imprisonment.
Even here, the figures are the most a court could impose. Where a court lands depends on the facts.
What should you do if you find an underpayment?
If you found it yourself, you can act before anyone else raises it. Here’s the order we’d work in.
- Fix the rate from the next pay run. Every extra week adds to the back pay.
- Work out the total. Use the calculator above for the scale, then work out each employee’s amount from your payroll records.
- Pay it back, and check whether super is owed on the same amounts.
- Find the cause. A wrong classification, a salary that doesn’t cover the award, a missed rate change. Fix the setting, not just the number.
- Keep a record of what you found, what you paid and when.
- Get advice early if the amount is large, or if anyone could say it was knowing or reckless. Lawpath Legal‘s employment lawyers can help with award compliance and working out your next steps.
If you need new employment contracts once the pay is fixed, our employment contract templates cover casual, full-time, part-time and fixed-term roles.
What you do next is the part you control.
What the calculator doesn’t do
It gives you a scale, and it’s only as right as what you enter. It doesn’t cover:
- Interest. A court can add it. The calculator doesn’t.
- Super. Super is owed on back pay for ordinary hours, and late super attracts the super guarantee charge.
- Each employee’s claim. It uses an average weekly shortfall across everyone. Each employee’s real amount depends on their own hours and rates.
- How courts group contraventions. It treats the underpayment as one contravention. A court might find several, or group them as a course of conduct.
- Penalty unit dates. It uses the penalty unit in force on the date the underpayment stopped.
- Headcount timing. It asks for your headcount now. The test that matters is the headcount when a court application is made.
Frequently asked questions
How far back can employees claim underpaid wages?
A court claim must be made within 6 years after the contravention, under s 544 of the Fair Work Act. The calculator counts back pay inside that window and shows anything older separately.
Is underpaying staff a criminal offence in Australia?
Only when it’s intentional. Since 1 January 2025, intentionally underpaying wages, super or other entitlements can be an offence under s 327A. Honest mistakes aren’t covered, and they stay a civil matter.
What is the maximum penalty for underpaying employees?
For a contravention on or after 1 July 2026: $21,840 for an individual, $109,200 for a company with fewer than 15 employees, and $546,000 or 3 times the underpayment for a company with 15 or more. Serious contraventions carry 10 times those fixed figures. Only a court can set the actual penalty.
Can a director be personally liable for underpaying staff?
Yes. Anyone involved in a contravention, such as a director or payroll manager, can be penalised personally under s 550, up to $21,840, or $218,400 if serious, for contraventions on or after 1 July 2026.
Does the calculator work out what each employee is owed?
No. It uses an average weekly shortfall across all affected employees to show the scale. Work out each employee’s amount from their own hours, rates and payroll records.
Know the number, then fix it
An underpayment you find yourself is a payroll problem you can fix. The back pay is owed either way, and the penalty figures are ceilings.
Run your figures through the underpayment calculator above, pay what’s owed and fix the cause before the next pay run.
This article is general information only and isn’t legal or financial advice. Penalty unit values change, so check the current figures and get advice for your situation.
