Unfair Dismissal Eligibility Checker for Australian Employers

Unfair Dismissal Eligibility Checker for Australian Employers
Table of Contents

Share at:

An unfair dismissal claim has to clear a set of eligibility tests before anyone asks whether the dismissal was fair. The Fair Work Commission checks those first. Our free unfair dismissal eligibility checker (below) runs the same eligibility tests and gives you the date the employee’s time to apply runs out.

Those tests are mechanical. Six months of service, or 12 if you have fewer than 15 employees. An award, an enterprise agreement or earnings under $190,100. A real dismissal, not a resignation or a contract that ran its course. Then two defences that stop a claim: a genuine redundancy, and for a small business, following the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. Get the answer before you give notice, and you’ll know how much the process matters.

Who can make an unfair dismissal claim?

Section 382 of the Fair Work Act 2009 protects an employee from unfair dismissal once two things are true. They’ve completed the minimum employment period, and a modern award covers them, an enterprise agreement applies to them, or their earnings are below the high income threshold. Section 385 then says a dismissal is only unfair if it was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, wasn’t consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, and wasn’t a genuine redundancy.

The Commission deals with the gateway questions first. Section 396 says it must decide whether the application was on time, whether the person was protected, whether the Code was followed and whether it was a genuine redundancy, before it looks at the merits. The Commission adds one more starting point: the employer has to be in the national workplace relations system. The checker runs these tests in order:

TestWhat stops a claimFair Work Act
National systemYour business is outside the national system, for example a state government employer, or a sole trader, partnership or trust in WAs 14
DismissalA voluntary resignation, or a fixed-term contract that ended at its end dates 386
Minimum employment periodFewer than 6 months of service when notice is given, or 12 months for a small business employerss 382, 383, 384
Award, agreement or earningsNo award or enterprise agreement, and earnings at or above $190,100 (2026-27)s 382(b)
Genuine redundancyThe job is no longer needed, you consulted as required and redeployment wasn’t reasonables 389
Small Business Fair Dismissal CodeYou have fewer than 15 employees and you followed the Codes 388

Pass every test and the checker returns likely eligible. That doesn’t mean the employee wins. It means the Commission will look at whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, using the factors in s 387, such as a valid reason, a chance to respond and warnings about performance. Our guide to unfair dismissal from the employer perspective covers that part.

The minimum employment period

Section 383 sets the minimum employment period by the size of your business:

Your businessMinimum employment period
15 or more employees6 months
Fewer than 15 employees (a small business employer)12 months

Four details decide the real date.

Count heads, including the person leaving. Section 23 counts every employee you have when notice is given, including the employee being dismissed and anyone else dismissed at the same time. Casuals count only if they’re regular casuals. Associated entities count as one employer. The Fair Work Ombudsman says the count happens when the employee is given notice, or when the employment ends if there was no notice.

Months are calendar months. The Commission says a 6-month period starting on 26 February finishes at midnight on 25 August. With no matching date, it finishes at the end of the month.

The clock stops at notice. The period ends at the earlier of the time the employee is given notice of the dismissal and immediately before the dismissal. A long notice period doesn’t carry an employee over the line.

Casual service counts only if it was regular. Under s 384(2)(a), time as a casual counts only if the employee was a regular casual with a reasonable expectation of continuing work on a regular and systematic basis. That matters for someone who started casual and later went full-time. If the casual work was irregular, the checker counts service from the day they became full-time or part-time. Our post on whether a casual employee can make an unfair dismissal claim explains the test.

Probation doesn’t change any of this. It’s a contract term, and the Act doesn’t link it to the minimum employment period. Our probation notice period checker works through that overlap.

The high income threshold for 2026-27

The high income threshold only matters for employees with no award and no enterprise agreement. Those employees are protected only if their annual rate of earnings is less than the threshold. The Commission sets it at:

Dismissal took effectHigh income thresholdFinancial year
1 July 2026 onwards$190,1002026-27
1 July 2025 to 30 June 2026$183,1002025-26

Earnings include wages and the agreed value of non-monetary benefits, such as private use of a company car. They don’t include superannuation guarantee contributions, commissions, bonuses, or overtime that isn’t guaranteed. A manager on a $185,000 base with a discretionary $40,000 bonus is under the 2026-27 threshold. The bonus can’t be determined in advance, so it’s left out.

If a modern award covers the employee or an enterprise agreement applies, earnings don’t matter for this test. Check award coverage by the work the employee does, not by their pay.

Was it a dismissal?

Section 386 defines dismissal. It covers employment terminated on your initiative, and a resignation the employee was forced into because of your conduct or a course of conduct. It doesn’t cover:

  • Employment under a contract for a specified period, task or season that ends at the end of the period, task or season (s 386(2)(a)).
  • Employment limited to a training arrangement that ends when the arrangement ends (s 386(2)(b)).
  • A demotion that doesn’t involve a significant cut to pay or duties, where the employee stays employed (s 386(2)(c)).

The fixed-term exception doesn’t apply if a substantial purpose of using that kind of contract was to avoid unfair dismissal obligations (s 386(3)). End a fixed-term contract early and it’s a dismissal on your initiative. Our guide on whether fixed-term contracts can be terminated early covers that.

Forced resignations are where employers get caught. If the employee says they resigned because of how they were treated, the Commission decides on the facts whether it was really a dismissal. The checker treats it as a dismissal and marks it “Check this”. Our post on whether forcing an employee to resign is grounds for unfair dismissal has more.

Genuine redundancy

A genuine redundancy isn’t an unfair dismissal (s 385(d)). The Commission says it’s genuine when all of these hold:

  • You no longer need anyone to do the person’s job, because of changes in the operational requirements of your business.
  • You complied with any obligation in an applicable modern award or enterprise agreement to consult about the redundancy.
  • It wouldn’t have been reasonable to redeploy the person within your business or the business of an associated entity.

Fail any one and it isn’t a genuine redundancy, so the Commission can look at whether the dismissal was unfair. The checker asks all three. If you haven’t looked at redeployment, it says so, because “we didn’t consider it” is a weak answer in a hearing. If you hire someone else to do the same job, the job was still needed, and the first test fails.

Genuine redundancy is a defence to unfair dismissal only. It doesn’t remove redundancy pay. Our employee redundancy guide covers the process and the pay.

If you’re a small business: the Fair Dismissal Code

If you had fewer than 15 employees when you gave notice, a dismissal that complied with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code isn’t unfair (s 385(c) and s 388). The Commission summarises what the Code expects:

  • Summary dismissal. You can dismiss without notice or a warning if you believe on reasonable grounds that the conduct is serious enough to justify immediate dismissal. The Code’s examples include theft, fraud, violence and serious breaches of health and safety procedures.
  • Other dismissals. Give a valid reason based on conduct or capacity, warn the employee that they could be dismissed if there’s no improvement, and give them a chance to respond and a reasonable chance to fix the problem.
  • Support person. Let the employee have another person present in discussions where dismissal is possible. That person can’t be a lawyer acting in a professional capacity.
  • Proof. If the employee makes a claim, you have to prove you complied.

Pick “Not sure” in the checker and it treats the Code as not followed. That’s deliberate. If you can’t show the warning, the response and the time to improve, the Code won’t help you. See our guides to the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code and how to dismiss an employee under it.

The 21-day lodgement deadline

An unfair dismissal application must be made within 21 days after the dismissal took effect (s 394(2)). The Commission explains how it counts:

  • The day the dismissal took effect isn’t counted. Day 1 is the next day.
  • Weekends and public holidays inside the 21 days still count.
  • If day 21 falls on a weekend, or a public holiday when the Commission is closed, the deadline moves to the next business day. The Commission closes on New Year’s Day, Australia Day, Good Friday, Easter Monday, Anzac Day, Christmas Day and Boxing Day, or the substitute days.

The checker gives day 21 and moves a weekend day 21 to the Monday. It doesn’t move the date for public holidays, so check the date if it lands on one. After the deadline, the Commission can allow a late application only in exceptional circumstances (s 394(3)).

For an employer, the date matters for a plain reason. Until it passes, you don’t know whether a claim is coming. A general protections dismissal claim has the same 21-day limit (s 366).

Unfair dismissal eligibility worked examples

These come straight from the checker. In each one the employer is in the national system and the employee is full-time.

Example 1: a performance dismissal after 6 months

You have 25 employees. An award-covered employee started on Monday 4 May 2026. After a performance process, you give notice on Tuesday 24 November 2026 with a last day of Tuesday 1 December 2026.

TestResult
Minimum employment period (6 months)Completed at the end of Tue 3 November 2026. Service at notice: 6 months and 21 days
Award, agreement or earningsA modern award covers the employee
EligibilityLikely eligible for unfair dismissal
Lodgement deadlineTue 22 December 2026 (day 1 is Wed 2 December 2026)

The employee clears every gate, so the dispute would be about the process: whether there was a valid reason, warnings and a fair chance to respond. With 25 staff the Code doesn’t apply. If the Commission ordered compensation, it couldn’t exceed the lesser of 26 weeks’ pay and $95,050, half the 2026-27 threshold (s 392(5)).

Example 2: a small business, 9 months in

You have 11 employees. The employee started on Monday 2 February 2026. You give notice on Wednesday 25 November 2026 with a last day of Wednesday 2 December 2026. You’re not sure you followed the Code.

TestResult
Minimum employment period (12 months, small business)Completed at the end of Mon 1 February 2027. Notice came 69 days before Tue 2 February 2027
Small Business Fair Dismissal CodeTreated as not followed
EligibilityLikely not eligible for unfair dismissal
Lodgement deadlineWed 23 December 2026

The employee has 9 months and 24 days of service at notice. With 11 employees, the period is 12 months, so the claim stops at the minimum employment period, whatever happened with the Code. Hire four more people before you give notice and the answer flips: at 15 employees the period is 6 months, which this employee has passed.

Example 3: a redundancy, with and without a redeployment option

You have 40 employees. An award-covered employee started on Monday 1 July 2024. Their role goes in a restructure. You consult as the award requires and give notice on Monday 30 November 2026, with a last day of Monday 14 December 2026.

RedeploymentGenuine redundancy?Eligibility
No reasonable redeployment was availableYesLikely not eligible for unfair dismissal
Redeployment would have been reasonableNo (s 389(2))Likely eligible for unfair dismissal

Everything else is the same: 2 years and 5 months of service, an award, and a lodgement deadline of Mon 4 January 2027. The redeployment answer decides it. If there was a vacant role the employee could reasonably have done, in your business or a related company, the redundancy isn’t genuine.

Example 4: an award-free manager and the threshold

You have 60 employees. A manager with no award or agreement started on Monday 12 January 2026. You give notice on Tuesday 1 December 2026 with a last day of Tuesday 29 December 2026.

Annual earningsResultLodgement deadline
$195,000Likely not eligible: at or above the $190,100 threshold (2026-27)Tue 19 January 2027
$185,000Likely eligible: below the thresholdTue 19 January 2027

The 6-month period was completed at the end of Sat 11 July 2026, so earnings decide it. Work out the annual rate the way the Commission does: base pay and agreed non-monetary benefits in, super guarantee and bonuses out.

What this checker doesn’t do

  • It doesn’t decide whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. That turns on the reason and the process (s 387).
  • It doesn’t assess general protections or discrimination claims, which have no minimum employment period or high income threshold. See unfair dismissal versus general protections.
  • It doesn’t cover state unfair dismissal schemes for employers outside the national system.
  • It doesn’t move the deadline for public holidays or decide transfer of business questions, where service with a previous employer can count.
  • It doesn’t work out notice or final pay. Use our Notice Period Calculator and Final Pay Calculator for those.

Unfair dismissal eligibility FAQs

How long do you have to work somewhere to claim unfair dismissal?

At least 6 months, or 12 months if the employer has fewer than 15 employees. The period is measured to the day the employee is given notice of the dismissal, or immediately before the dismissal if that’s earlier (Fair Work Act s 383).

What is the high income threshold for unfair dismissal in 2026-27?

$190,100 for dismissals that take effect from 1 July 2026. It was $183,100 for dismissals from 1 July 2025 to 30 June 2026. It only matters if no modern award or enterprise agreement covers the employee.

Can a casual employee claim unfair dismissal?

Yes, if their casual service was regular and systematic and they had a reasonable expectation of continuing work, and they meet the other tests. Irregular casual service doesn’t count towards the minimum employment period (s 384(2)(a)).

Can an employee claim unfair dismissal after a redundancy?

Not if it was a genuine redundancy: the job is no longer needed because of operational changes, you consulted as the award or agreement requires, and redeployment wasn’t reasonable. If any part fails, they can claim.

Does the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code stop a claim?

If you had fewer than 15 employees and you followed the Code, the dismissal isn’t unfair. You have to prove you complied, so keep the warnings and notes of each discussion.

How long does an employee have to lodge an unfair dismissal claim?

21 days after the dismissal took effect, not counting that day. If day 21 falls on a weekend or a public holiday when the Commission is closed, it moves to the next business day. Late applications need exceptional circumstances.

Can an employee who resigned claim unfair dismissal?

Only if they were forced to resign because of the employer’s conduct or a course of conduct. A voluntary resignation isn’t a dismissal (s 386).

Check eligibility before you give notice

Run the checker before the meeting. If the employee can’t claim, a fair process is still good practice, and general protections still apply. If they can, the process is what you’ll be judged on, so slow down and get it right.

And if a claim does arrive, our guide to dealing with unfair dismissal claims explains what happens next.

Get your Full Time Employment Agreement legal document for free.

Hire your employees and protect your business with our full time employment agreement.

This article is general information only and isn’t legal advice. Rules are as at 22 November 2026 and can change, so check the Fair Work Act, the Fair Work Commission and your award or agreement, and get advice for your situation.

Share at:

Simplify creating legal documents today

Browse through Lawpath's AI tools which can be used to draft, review and refine legal documents today!

Related Articles

What is a General Security Agreement (GSA)?

Have you been asked to sign a general security agreement (GSA) to secure a commercial loan? Read this guide to understand what it entails.

5 Questions to Ask When Hiring an Estate Planning Lawyer

Your guide to future-proof your assets

What are Standard Form Contracts?

Want to increase efficiency of your business? Learn all about standard form contracts and factors to consider when creating them here.

How to Respond to a Cease and Desist Letter (2026 Update)

Receiving a Cease and Desist Letter can be highly concerning. Find out in this article how to respond to a Cease and Desist Letter.

5 Advantages of Hiring a Virtual Assistant For Your Business

What are virtual assistants and what can they provide? Read their advantages and decide if they are the right fit for your business.

Tidal wave of piracy costs Kanye The Life of Pablo

Read about the obstacle Kanye's latest album is facing.

The $1 Levy Across Taxi Services

Deserved Compensation or An Insufficient Safety Net for Taxi Drivers?

What’s The Difference Between A Corporation And A Company?

Understand the definitions of corporation vs company under Australian law and choose the right business structure for you.
jury

What Happens if an Employee is Called for Jury Duty?

Has one of your employees been called for jury duty? Are you wondering what this involves? Read this article to learn about jury duty and how it affects the workplace.