Secret Recordings: The New ‘Evidence’ of 2016?

Share at:

In the age of digital transparency and viral videos, we’ve all been privy to watching a covertly recorded video or conversation leaked with the intention of providing an “insider” perspective into a story.

For most of us, the desire to watch these secret recordings is not merely a case of curious voyeurism but more focused on our ever-increasing efforts to pursue the truth in light of controversial or public issues. When Kim Kardashian West leaked a secret video recording of Taylor Swift agreeing to Kanye West’s “Famous” lyrics, social media erupted in a swarm of ‘snake’ emojis with fans shocked over the unexpected disclosure. Similarly, while alleged secret recordings of fundraisers linked to the Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton fuelled widespread media speculation, her counterpart Donald Trump came under significant heat for comments made regarding women in a leaked conversation.

The legality of these recordings is a crucial aspect that requires further exploration. The recent Brisbane Supreme Court case over the death of Warriena Wright on her Tinder date with accused Gable Tostee depicted how secretly taped conversations can play a vital role as evidence in a trial. Importantly, was Mr Tostee within his right to make such a recording seemingly without the knowledge of Ms Wright?

Is it legal?

Under section 43 of the Privacy Act 1971 (Qld), a person may legally secretly record a face to face conversation you are having with someone. However it is unlawful to use a listening device to overhear, record, monitor or listen to a private conversation that you are not a party to. These restrictions are also applicable in the states of Victoria and the Northern Territory.

In New South Wales, the strict regulations of the Surveillance Devices Act 2007 (NSW) provide that recorded conversations are only legal where permission has been obtained from all parties involved or where the principal party believes that the recording is “reasonably necessary” to protect their interests. However the recording cannot be published or recorded for the purposes of publication without consent.

Workplace surveillance

Additionally more stringent restrictions also apply in relation to workplace surveillance including recording and monitoring of conversations that occur by email, messages or orally.

In New South Wales, the Workplace Surveillance Act 2005 (NSW) expressly prohibits covert surveillance, meaning any secret surveillance that is undertaken without the knowledge of the employee(s). The Act strictly prohibits covert surveillance unless the employer obtains a ‘covert surveillance authority’ which has been issued by a Magistrate authorising the surveillance to determine whether the employee(s) are involved in unlawful activity at work.

Can secret recordings be used in Court?

Generally evidence that has been unlawfully recorded is inadmissible in all states. In most states, including New South Wales, certain circumstances may allow an admission of the recording if the Courts believe that the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighs the undesirability of how it was obtained.

In determining this, the Court may take into consideration factors including:

  • the importance of the evidence;
  • the nature of the offence;
  • the gravity of the contravention in obtaining the evidence; and
  • the difficulty of obtaining evidence without contravention of law.

Conclusion

Despite the value that a secret recordings can provide, it is important to remember that there are legislative provisions which govern if and how we can record and use covertly obtained footage. Remember to check your state regulations to avoid potential legal disputes before you hit ‘record’ and ‘share to Facebook’ on your smartphone!

Let us know your thoughts on secret recordings by letting by tagging us using #lawpath or @lawpath.


Share at:

Most Popular Articles
You may also like
Recent Articles

Get the latest news

Name

By clicking on 'Sign up to our newsletter' you are agreeing to the Lawpath Terms & Conditions

eBook
Download our eBook,
Hiring Your First Employee

Our eBook covers the necessary legal and financial considerations you should make when hiring your first employee.

Name

You may also like

What Happens To A Pet After A Divorce?

Find out who keeps the beloved family pet after a divorce.
What Is The Maximum Number Of Partners A Partnership Can Have?

What Is The Maximum Number Of Partners A Partnership Can Have?

So you already decided to start a partnership and have drawn up a written partnership agreement, but did you know that there is a cap on the number of partners you can have for your partnership?

What’s A Reverse Mortgage?

Reverse mortgages can be a great option for those entering retirement - but it's not without its risks.
Emille Mendoza

Sharing the Benefits of Nature: Interview with Boracay Skin

In this article we talk to Emille Mendoza from Boracay Skin about her business and what motivates her everyday.

How Can You Remove A Director From Your Company? A Complete Guide

Do you plan to remove a director from your company? Here is a guide on how to legally remove a director from your company

When is Service of Legal Documents on a Business Valid (NSW)?

Properly serving a legal document is an important process in court proceedings. Read more about the rules on serving a Business or Company here.

Employer Responsibilities For Staff Working From Home

Working from home has suddenly become the norm for many Australians. Find out what your rights are and what responsibilities your employer has.
Recruiter interviewing a candidate at a recruitment agency in Australia

How to Start a Recruitment Agency in Australia: 10 Steps

Master the legal framework for launching your recruitment business in Australia. Expert guidance on compliance, licensing, and setup.

What Legal Services do I need to Hire an Employee?

Hiring an Employee? Learn about the legal documents you will need in place to safeguard your business and employees.