Oprah prevails in the ‘Own Your Power’ trademark dispute!

Table of Contents

Share at:

When Oprah chants,“Own Your Power,” the screaming crowd of adoring fans feel empowered. Picture Tom Cruise jumping on the sofa completely owning his power.

However the phrase had Simone Kelly-Brown, a motivational speaker, business coach, and owner of the company Own Your Power Communications Inc feeling a different way.

Kelly-Brown registered a ‘design mark’ for ‘Own Your Power’ in a stylised light-blue script with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in May 2008 and claimed that Oprah cannot use the phrase in her namesake magazine, social events, television, websites and social media.

However, the Appeals Court decided in favour of Oprah Winfrey and let’s learn why.

Why ‘Own Your Power’ couldn’t be trademarked?

There were three grounds that supported Oprah’s use of the phrase:

1. ‘Own Your Power’ is ‘not distinctive’ enough

‘Own Your Power’ standing alone was not held to be distinctive and lacked independent protection. The phrase was considered to be ‘descriptive’, ‘suggestive’ and ‘arbitrary or fanciful’ and incapable of having any secondary meaning.

2. The phrase did not create any likelihood of confusion

There was no evidence that could be shown to prove that the phrase ‘own your power’ created any confusion. For this purpose, there cannot be a ‘possibility of confusion’ but a proved ‘probability of confusion’ which Simone Kelly-Brown and her legal team could not prove.

3. The trademark protection was for the composite mark and not the phrase

A composite mark is a trademark that consists of both a word or slogan and a design or logo. In this case, the composite mark combined with design elements could have been protected but not the phrase per se as the phrase was merely descriptive of the products of the business.

The outcome may have some implications for Australia. What do you do if you have an award-winning phrase that you have just coined?

Can I trademark a phrase?

Yes, you can! To quote a phrase from the 2008 Obama campaign – In the US, if you are able to show distinctiveness and no creation of confusion, you can trademark a phrase. Although most countries have similar systems for registration and enforcement of trademarks, there are a few differences.

For example – In Australia, there is no requirement to show a ‘likelihood of confusion’ to prove infringement of a trademark which also explains why Australian practitioners generally draft broader specifications of goods and services for which a trademark application is made as opposed to their US counterparts.

Find out if you can trademark a phrase with LawPath’s helpful guide.

Looking to trademark a phrase? LawPath can arrange a fixed price quote to connect you with a trademark attorney who can provide you expert guidance to assist with your trademark registration.

Let us know your thoughts on registering a phrase as a trademark by tagging us #lawpath or @lawpath.

Share at:

Simplify creating legal documents today

Browse through Lawpath's AI tools which can be used to draft, review and refine legal documents today!

Related Articles

The Gift that Keeps on Giving: Gift Card Laws in NSW

NSW Government introduces new minimum expiry date laws for gift cards.
How Does a Creditors Scheme of Arrangement Work?

How Does a Creditors Scheme of Arrangement Work?

A creditors' scheme of arrangement is a way that a company can restructure its debts. However, a strict process must be followed. Find out more here.

What’s Peer To Peer (P2P) Lending?

How Peer to Peer (P2P) lending can be a great way to raise capital for your business.

What Legal Documents do I need to Hire an Independent Contractor?

Need to hire a contractor? Learn about the legal documents and services you will need in place to safeguard your business.

Business Lines of Credit in Australia: Unlock Flexible Financing for Your SME

In this guide, we’ll break down exactly how business lines of credit work in Australia, explain your options, outline eligibility criteria, and show you how to apply for and manage credit. 

Memorandum Of Understanding vs Contract: When To Use What

A memorandum of understanding (MOU) can be a great asset to contract negotiation. Here are our tips on when to use an MOU, and what to avoid when drafting one.

How Does Turnover Rent Work and Why Should I Use It?

Turnover rent is a different way businesses can pay for rent to their landlord. It can sometimes be referred to as percentage rent.

What’s the Difference between Mutual and Segregated Funds?

What is the difference between a mutual fund and segregated fund? What are their similarities? Which one should you choose? Read more to find out.

How to Find Out if You’re Entitled to a Tax Refund 

Have you lodged a tax return lately? If you haven't, you might be missing out on a refund from the tax office. Read this guide to find out how to claim it.