What is a Notice to Show Cause?

Did you receive a notice to show cause? Do you need to issue a show-cause letter to an employee or supplier? Whether you’re an employee facing disciplinary action or a business owner dealing with regulatory issues, understanding the nature and implications of these letters is crucial. 

In this guide, we will explain show cause letters in the Australian context and provide you with the knowledge and tools to respond to and craft show cause letters effectively.

What is a show cause letter or notice to show cause?

A show cause letter, also known as a notice to show cause, is a formal document issued by an employer, regulatory body, or legal authority that asks the recipient to provide an explanation or justification for their actions or conduct. 

This type of letter is usually an important step in disciplinary or legal proceedings because it allows the recipient to respond to allegations before any final decisions are made.

In Australia, show cause letters are often used in the following circumstances:

  • Workplace disciplinary processes
  • Regulatory compliance matters
  • Legal proceedings
  • Professional licensing and accreditation

Show cause letter example: licensed businesses

NSW Fair Trading manages a range of consumer protection legislation that requires individuals within a particular industry to be licensed. The agency provides licenses and certificates to a variety of industry members. This includes conveyancers, motor vehicle repairers, pawnbrokers, second-hand dealers, motor dealers, builders, and electricians.

If you are involved in the operation of a licensed business and NSW Fair Trading believes you have breached the law, you may face disciplinary action. The first step in this disciplinary action would be a notice to show cause.

Purpose and implications of a show cause letter

Receiving a show cause letter is a serious matter. If you have received one, it requires your immediate attention. Here are some reasons why you might be issued a show cause letter. 

  • Ensuring procedural fairness: The ‘show cause process’ upholds the principles of natural justice because it gives the recipient the opportunity to respond to allegations.
  • Gathering information: Show cause letters also allow the issuing party to obtain additional information or explanations before making a final decision.
  • Initiating formal proceedings: In many cases, a show cause letter marks the beginning of a formal disciplinary or legal process.
  • Protecting legal rights: By documenting the allegations and giving the recipient a chance to respond, the show cause process helps protect both parties’ legal rights.

If you fail to provide appropriate reasons as to why the issuing authority should not take action against you, then you may be subject to a variety of disciplinary actions. Consequently, if the breach of law is minor, the disciplinary action may be a formal caution or reprimand. 

More substantive responses include a monetary penalty or condition on your license. The most serious penalties, however, include canceling your license or disqualifying an entity from holding or obtaining a license in the future.

Find the perfect lawyer to help your business today!

Get a fixed-fee quote from Australia's largest lawyer marketplace.

How to reply to a show cause notice

It’s important that you properly respond to a show cause letter. This can protect your interests and potentially avoid severe consequences. Here’s a step-by-step guide to crafting an appropriate reply. 

  1. Read and understand the letter: Carefully review the allegations and requested information. Make note of any deadlines for response.
  2. Gather evidence: Collect any relevant documents, emails, or witness statements that support your case.
  3. Address each allegation: Respond to each point raised in the letter, providing clear explanations and supporting evidence where possible.
  4. Acknowledge any mistakes: If applicable, take responsibility for any errors and explain steps taken to rectify the situation.
  5. Propose solutions: If appropriate, suggest ways to address the concerns raised in the letter.

If you have received a notice to show cause, it is best to contact either an industry association or a business lawyer. The respondent will usually have 14 days to reply to a notice to show cause. However, the notice you receive will specify the response deadline. 

Subsequently, if you fail to respond within the provided timeline, you may face disciplinary action. For example, if this is related to your business license, the consequences can be as serious as the removal of your license without further opportunity to show cause. 

Of course, you may be able to appeal any decisions at a later date. That said, you will have to contend with having your licensing suspended in the meanwhile. 

Types of show cause letters

Show cause letters can vary depending on the context and issuing authority. Here are some common types. 

Often issued to employees, show cause letters in the workplace address problems like performance, misconduct, and harassment. 

  • Performance-related: You can issue a letter to an employee who consistently fails to meet job expectations or performance targets.
  • Misconduct: Sent in response to alleged violations of workplace policies or codes of conduct.
  • Absenteeism: Used when an employee has excessive or unexplained absences from work.
  • Harassment or bullying: You can issue this type of letter in response to complaints of workplace harassment or bullying behaviour.

As a business owner, you may receive a show cause notice due to non-compliance with different types of regulations. 

  • Licensing violations: Sent by regulatory bodies like NSW Fair Trading if you breach licensing conditions.
  • Health and safety breaches: If your workplace fails to comply with health and safety regulations, you may receive a show cause letter. 
  • Environmental compliance: Used by environmental protection agencies for alleged breaches of environmental laws.
  • Financial regulation: A financial regulatory body may send a notice for suspected violations of financial laws and regulations.

Show cause letters are not limited to workplace situations. There are many other legal areas that use these types of letters to initiate legal proceedings. 

  • Breach of contract: You may issue or be issued a show cause letter if there are problems surrounding the fulfillment of contractual obligations.
  • Lease termination: Landlords may send a letter to tenants for violations of lease agreements.
  • Debt recovery: Used by creditors as a formal step before initiating legal action for unpaid debts.
  • Professional misconduct: Issued by professional bodies or associations for alleged breaches of professional standards or ethics.

How to write a show cause notice

If you need to issue a show cause letter, it’s essential to craft a clear, comprehensive, and legally sound document. Here’s a guide to writing an effective show cause notice.

  1. Use official letterhead: Present the notice on company or organisation letterhead to establish its formal nature.
  2. Clearly state the purpose: Begin with a clear statement that this is a show cause notice and briefly explain its purpose.
  3. Provide specific details: Clearly outline the allegations or concerns, including dates, times, and specific incidents where applicable.
  4. Reference relevant policies or regulations: Cite any workplace policies, contractual clauses, or legal regulations that have allegedly been breached.
  5. Explain potential consequences: Clearly state the possible disciplinary actions or outcomes if the recipient fails to provide a satisfactory response.
  6. Set a clear deadline: Specify the timeframe within which the recipient must respond. This is often set to 14 days but can vary based on the specific circumstances. 
  7. Offer the opportunity for a meeting: If appropriate, include information about the possibility of a face-to-face meeting to discuss the matter.
  8. Provide guidance for a response format: Explain how the recipient should submit their response and whom they should contact. 

Throughout your letter, make sure to maintain a neutral tone and keep the language factual and professional. Avoid any emotional or accusatory statements — remember that this letter may be later used in legal proceedings. 

Want more?

Sign up for our newsletter and be the first to find hand-picked articles on topics that we believe are crucial to successfully scale your unique small business.

By clicking on 'Sign up to our newsletter' you are agreeing to the Lawpath Terms & Conditions

Common mistakes to avoid when responding to a show-cause letter

On the other hand, if you are preparing a response to a show cause notice, then you should keep some of the following issues in mind to craft an effective reply. 

Missing the deadline

One of the most critical mistakes is failing to respond within the specified timeframe. Ignoring or overlooking the deadline can lead to automatic disciplinary action, which may include severe consequences such as termination or loss of licensure. 

To avoid this, set a reminder as soon as you receive the letter. Prioritise your response by drafting it immediately, and give yourself ample time for revisions before submission. 

Being overly emotional or defensive

Another common error is allowing emotions to cloud your judgment when responding. It’s natural to feel defensive, but maintaining a professional tone is crucial. Focus on the facts rather than letting emotions dictate your response. Avoid making false statements, as they can exacerbate your situation and damage your credibility. 

Ignoring specific allegations

It’s vital not to overlook any specific allegations mentioned in the show cause letter. Address each point raised directly in your response. Failing to do so can give the impression that you are dismissive of the concerns raised. 

If you need to acknowledge any mistakes, provide context and explain the steps you have taken — or plan to take — to rectify the situation. 

Providing insufficient evidence

You should always support explanations with relevant documentation. As such, before drafting your reply, gather all pertinent documents, emails, and other forms of evidence that substantiate your account. If applicable, include statements from colleagues or witnesses who can corroborate your perspective. 

Again, consulting with a legal professional or industry expert can provide valuable insights into how best to approach your situation. 

Final thoughts

If you have been issued a show cause letter, then the first step is not to panic. Instead, thoroughly understand your rights and responsibilities and craft a meaningful, detailed response to protect your interests. 

Meanwhile, if you are planning to issue a show cause letter, be sure to understand the information you need to include and the implications of issuing such a notice. 

Remember, each case is unique, and seeking professional legal advice is often the best course of action when faced with a show cause letter. If you are unsure, it’s best to hire a lawyer and ensure legal compliance throughout this tricky process. 

Don't know where to start?

Contact us on 1800 529 728 to learn more about customising legal documents, obtaining a fixed-fee quote from our network of 600+ expert lawyers or to get answers to your legal questions.

Register for our free live webinar today!

Hiring Your First Employee: Get it Right from the Start

12:00pm AEDT
Tuesday 28th January 2025

By clicking on 'Register for webinar' you are agreeing to the Lawpath Terms & Conditions

You may also like

If you have received a scary email about another party trying to trademark your business name, there's no need to panic. Learn to spot the red flags and what to do next.
Copyright can be a valuable asset for your business. Read on to get a handle on the basics.
Considering an employee stock ownership plan for your business? Our guide on ESOPs can help!

Thank you!

Your registration is confirmed. Keep an eye on your inbox for an email with details on how to watch the webinar.